Overview
What follows is the useful part: the two things the backhand index pointing right is actually for (linking to the article someone just posted and pointing out the person who should answer this), the reading it gets when it is not what the sender meant, and the five tone pages that sit under this one.
There is not a lot to the picture. π is a hand with the index finger extended, pointing right with the palm turned inward, added in Unicode 6.0 and filed under hand-single-finger. What it does in a message is carry a meaning β here, directing attention at something beside you β without anyone having to write it out.
That plain reading is the one most people arrive with, and it is usually the intended one. The picture is doing the same work as the sentence it replaces, and it lands first.
The complication is that the drawing invites a second reading. It gets taken as an accusation when it is nearly always a nudge toward a link, a name, or a person β the sideways orientation makes it feel less pointed than a face-on finger. In practice that second reading is not rare β it is the one that decides how a message lands, because the sender has usually not thought about it at all.
It also sits in the crowded part of the picker. The nearest neighbour is π«΅ Index Pointing at the Viewer: the viewer-facing finger reads as pointing at you, the rightward one reads as pointing at something off-screen. The two are close enough that a fast thumb picks the wrong one, and the message goes out carrying a meaning nobody chose.
There are five tone versions of this emoji, and they are not copies of this page. Each one describes the same gesture from inside a different group, because a tone is read as a signal about the sender before the sentence is read.
How People Use It
The common uses are linking to the article someone just posted and pointing out the person who should answer this. The first one is about speed β the picture replaces the explanation, and it lands before the words would have. The second is about tone β the sentence stands on its own, and the emoji is there to change how it reads.
The same emoji in three rooms: a family thread, a work channel, and a dating app. In the first it closes a conversation, in the second it hands something over, in the third it is a joke with an eyebrow raised. The drawing never changes; the expectation of the reader does.
That is also the reason the skin-tone variants are written as their own pages rather than as one page with a table of swatches. A tone is not a setting, and it is read differently.
Look at how often π is used to avoid typing. A question goes out, a question comes back, and in between there is a single picture standing in for an answer that would have taken a sentence. It reads as "directing attention at something beside you", which is fine until it is not.
When Not to Use It
Watch the picker, and watch the thread. π is easy to send when π«΅ Index Pointing at the Viewer was meant β the viewer-facing finger reads as pointing at you, the rightward one reads as pointing at something off-screen. And the emoji has no business being the whole reply to somebody who has just told you something bad: it reads as "directing attention at something beside you", which is about the gesture rather than about them.
The problem is not the emoji, it is the message underneath it. π gets taken as an accusation when it is nearly always a nudge toward a link, a name, or a person β the sideways orientation makes it feel less pointed than a face-on finger, and the drift happens silently. Nobody notices that the meaning changed, because the change was in a picture.
Nor is it a good opener with a stranger. The drawing is cold, and backhand index pointing right gestures have collected a faintly superior edge from being used to reply to other people for years.
Professional settings are the other place to leave it alone. Put π next to somebody's performance, or in a first note to a client, and directing attention at something beside you is the note it reads as β a note that costs more in a workplace than in a group chat.
How to Reply
Matching works when the message was a reaction: send π back and the tone is confirmed without a word. It does not work when the message was aimed at you. A request, a handover, a nudge β those want a sentence, because two gestures in a row leave the question open.
If you cannot tell how the backhand index pointing right was meant, read the line above it instead. π gets taken as an accusation when it is nearly always a nudge toward a link, a name, or a person β the sideways orientation makes it feel less pointed than a face-on finger; the sentence underneath is the part that disambiguates it.
Warmth needs words next to the picture. Something like linking to the article someone just posted sent with π on its own is a coin toss between directing attention at something beside you and something sharper, and the sender never gets to pick which one landed.